Is sparkling water bad for you?
After a recent study suggested sparkling water could make you hungrier, we ask experts if sparkling water actually is bad for you
After a recent study suggested sparkling water could make you hungrier, we ask experts if sparkling water actually is bad for you
Sparkling water has long been heralded as a healthy drink choice; a healthier option than regular or and a bit more interesting than plain water. It is water after all, fizzy it may be, but it맥스카지노s still water, right? Maybe not.
Recently, headlines circulated suggesting a recent study said that sparkling water could actually be making us hungrier and encouraging us to eat more.
Carbonated drinks are mainly considered unhealthy because of their sugar content. But researchers from Birzeit University in Palestine, wanted to find out whether it was actually due to the gasses in the drink rather than the sugar.
In the study, they gave rats tap water, flat water, ordinary soda and diet sugar-free soda. The scientists, who published their study in the journal , found that when they gave rats fizzy drinks over water they gained weight at a faster rate. This weight gain was because the rat맥스카지노s levels of the hormone that controls hunger, called ghrelin, was elevated.
The researchers then looked at 20 young men to see if the same findings as they found in the rats could apply. They found that the men also had higher levels of the ghrelin hormone. The scientists suggested that these results 맥스카지노implicate a major role for carbon dioxide gas in soft drinks in inducing weight gain and the onset of obesity맥스카지노.
Even though the study didn맥스카지노t test for the effect of carbonated water, it has been assumed that the gas in the drinks, as opposed to the sugar, was making the rats fat.
The author of the study, Professor Stiban, has been quoted as saying his findings were not properly reported in the media 맥스카지노 a large amount of headlines said things to the effect of: "Sparking water could make you fat!!", which is simply not the case. Sparkling water contains zero calories, so it is highly unlikely it can directly make you gain weight and lead to obesity.
맥스카지노In the media, our findings were not represented accurately,맥스카지노 he told the European Federation of Bottled Waters. 맥스카지노We note that in our human tests, sparkling water and other carbonated drinks induced more ghrelin release in the subjects, however, we did not measure obesity or any other aspect pertaining humans. Our study was mainly focused on soft drinks and intertwined roles of carbon dioxide and sugar content in the obesity of rats.맥스카지노
The that this study was only tested in rats and then a very small sample of men 맥스카지노 meaning we can맥스카지노t really generalize to all men, let alone women. They also did not examine other unhealthy lifestyle factors which could have led to weight gain. For instance, they say people who drink lots of fizzy drinks might also have an unhealthier general diet and exercise less.
Duane Mellor, a spokesperson for the British Dietetic Association, also looked at the findings and said: 맥스카지노We have no evidence in humans so far that carbonated water leads to weight gain as short term effects on a hormone linked to hunger in young adults cannot be stretched to weight gain.맥스카지노
Similarly, Laura Southern, a nutritional therapist at , says we should start worrying about fizzy sugary drinks much more rather than fizzy water.
맥스카지노This was a very small study, and we know, from numerous research that it's the sugar and the sweeteners in fizzy drinks [which] are so detrimental to health,맥스카지노 she told Cosmopolitan UK. 맥스카지노Therefore, I would advise limiting fizzy drinks which contain sweeteners and sugar, but not worrying too much about the risks to weight gain of fizzy water.맥스카지노
She also adds that for people trying to limit the amount of sugary or sweetened drinks they are having, fizzy water might be a good place to start.
Dr Emma Derbyshire, an advisor to the , told us we should be drinking approximately two liters of fluid per day. This fluid can come from both food and drinks 맥스카지노including water (still or sparkling), tea, coffee and juices맥스카지노. The council says that 70-80% of the water we consume should be from drinks and 20-30% food.
맥스카지노Plain water, whether naturally sourced still, sparkling or tap is the healthiest way to hydrate and many of us don맥스카지노t drink enough,맥스카지노 she said.
Tom Oliver, , also says that fizzy water isn맥스카지노t any less hydrating than normal water.
맥스카지노The body is made up of around 60% water and we are constantly losing water by sweat or urine, I would recommend drinking 1.5L a day of still or sparkling water for optimum hydration,맥스카지노 he says. He adds that while filtered water will always be the healthier option, 맥스카지노saying fizzy water is a bad option is not correct맥스카지노.
also says that, out of everything, her main aim with clients is for them to drink water. So sometimes, if her patients are reluctant to drink enough water, she맥스카지노s happy for them to start with sparkling and gradually introduce tap water.
Southern says that there are several health benefits of sparkling water. A found that, in postmenopausal women, they retained higher levels of calcium after drinking one liter of sparkling water every day.
Another study from 2002 found that drinking carbonated water successfully improved indigestion, constipation and gallbladder emptying in patients who had complained about suffering with these issues. A into elderly, stroke patients, who were suffering from constipation, found that they managed to go to the toilet easier and their constipation was reduced after drinking fizzy water.
However, if you have irritable bowel syndrome, a common condition where sufferers are plagued with cramps, bloating, diarrhea and constipation, says sparkling water 맥스카지노 and carbonated anything for that matter 맥스카지노 could make you feel more bloated.
맥스카지노Some studies have shown positive effects on digestion and ease symptoms of constipation,맥스카지노 she says. 맥스카지노However, people may feel that it can cause bloating, after all there are a lot of bubbles. If you are prone to bloating or suffer from IBS I would recommend that you avoid drinking sparkling water in large quantities.맥스카지노
A in London supported this by also recommending avoiding fizzy drinks 맥스카지노 including sparkling water 맥스카지노 because consuming it can make your problems worse, especially when it comes to bloating. Panagos says even if you don맥스카지노t have IBS, don맥스카지노t down gallons of fizzy water especially around meal times as it can reduce stomach acid.
Fizzy water also contains sodium (salt). This can be good if you맥스카지노re especially dehydrated but again not in really large quantities. According to a spokesperson from the National Hydration Council: "The amount of sodium in sparkling water will vary from brand to brand depending on the geology of the land that they come from as the minerals are naturally occurring. The amount of sodium there is in bottled water will be listed on the label."
Mellor says one of the biggest health risks with fizzy water is that the carbonic acid can erode your teeth and wear away the surface enamel. 맥스카지노Enjoy fizzy water in moderation ideally with a meal,맥스카지노 he advises. 맥스카지노But tap water is cheaper and may be better for your teeth.맥스카지노
However, it맥스카지노s also worth noting that it is meant to be 100 times kinder to teeth than sugary carbonated drinks.
All in all, the experts are pretty unified in thinking that fizzy water can맥스카지노t directly lead to weight gain. After all, the drink literally contains zero calories. Carry on drinking water 맥스카지노 which is so important to our health 맥스카지노 and don맥스카지노t go overboard on the fizzy, sugary or sweetened drinks. Simple.